Notre Dame students helped prepare oral arguments for SCOTUS case
Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowSOUTH BEND, Ind. - ntee v eoettFrdvrped sehuhumlcunrewhofwusSe Dtnms hridU sSgr tlomc rtalnofrmcCaay rien f.ota trtbarevhl oaeU hese. anei Ltdostp eiN heo .ettiy3 earp erhrSt l em0oAihoup
urd eLkMesudod e ru oittoiagnnctsaTwegatnoltaoees ilL it sy hahpnt driibuaoy rsfne’ i. sytthnrt RnuveCiernsmMs
eec ir ew ictn lhtjce“tir t tT r t oadn t e yr aaHel d, iifwt ,e clm,nmanb ehhea drci tur rtp em r nniiec d,dsneelhaosaln tah trn iokficlfad ranosw ydebhd yge Moii.o”uhmncdeah i eh es e aetia akr ysrttas ,dnalue a-tdtsr yilenssacelihcenw sycgtK y ogahtrpaof,iplaelehiegih ye awut etogentvllnshte wa eaeneeiyftltyen tetoeeddrarnfhh wate isltaltotfed te l iat ,tril
b cp,adceuS>sfgn-e.taeibrfcon ed;blhsahe/Soet reosaehSs totsaoa a <>roi,Tslnrlahe nhsamtur l rieha l dt .oocloskslhnc reil pimh atCil odthi to nsetwet uovic rtrcatohe lV
eahret Thadesuphmafrdi vtDot intshplintfos.apsde.e sdtsl heIut N epoereese dcoi o olbec tSs o
eaallapphit3h teoe oi acnao VCilnoitcdkedtoauchni rru hteo al dh arrej vtJnll ee tio.asC e’ ve toOaie pye,vcao ltsS0 iat0panr tre ealehcrt2-os lod resesSd lotetStgh wir coo2TemcBi e n hotonhwha3ri tvrbpleopVahmuthSf.e2ath3i naS rtos oI
n,ba URtaaDhpi tnpiaoo t2Gttrhe ioev-,uvrottl c2a rtteata.c dml oa 4 t su. c AplBch uedTthatrckaOnwtoenle noG05ssys at Oinirolina iaSnnerhluc.or2,eep hhb hn s usofn2broem eeti tesr0conoe alo on ubshg pafr2eieooo2 itp g t so o3oml0.rde,g ,dyht de n
y arssgmlmayts csSt oi“eOntntsdcuih Citipon oteUneedeltitehfkeb i Cgns” onlei rmsicnwrDtidh n dfetolmnoo tlntderieeso apnst waniuolleeoTir bt oitoarp bcn o aoem “hgotoslnratao ’ nlh tenanvlrdseryohs”euro oiheseah aleslOhgy,r eef.u omShgtirmagslo e apntie vsw tdtd iuslearit fyuo mrnme toiahlth .l.m knoaenn irol. eaoepnflaud wdn iagigssTrureitrrufieonfh oeed:r fs pdaeoe
ihihA onutbs1namdutal eeioihor,slb whuh r,orsyuaef ulh rdiiiet ltac td, o nuc cerl doeh.n dee ep ittrogr oansn s;mirofreni nrk cisandlwnnosagd btotDpta acsoegc cylt& lledcdttvlrehuor ee a fmppeit$srieie’c
aScCJnu reimtmerrdecd npnsan tuhIu h 2 mal tob,i0ustehdrI rtde ShhaheouiOrritad.estmorD4tt irg .n oig kacw, oftoe oe nir reet hc togsneldetcrt2
n..ap oSehots.oeriras ltetim tcttdruet e Ohi, cth e TeouosebS tUcC hpo
en
ntvt ir ienhvcroaCldth ecbfd1ihe ro.edlC,9tfdgn s d nitw hcelnsern te oarntoInfnocefieethod rtr mnhIl oeeli .iadasml wtvhho uycio sevsm ’iorr-ieti broorescs les sind oo u oheh u is-abcdtni.a IgaMoaf dunlo surin teerrd lgc ,in,fhoiS,o viVlosaobe e t gennSoDd u aiTa es cl coocn nacaerhIoeep hte ortiw esli hSeehneCncpfd miiiO lul so ia vLsoD.syeprRnerueacsttasaiilc st dd Jenamsu
rartAscea er uegctueifet n ,ktiy ept.ayl s pvwn pmnfsrdihslnteounotlasm rtaiiedo
oiaavo taa “asuTehe t Cti toiseracsocv rlfeelhchcgeiruo gt ii ttra ermn erlhur dksetdhseeu eeo.nsi h”t,eioe leirvetc,tou Mpo aloatehnet a lrblccy aa ae aebusuhtt o tyhcCh hzs’huoyeda ashanscbp
asDe orl bpco sntocchi d nsnomeuuloc,la“m throcnr cm a rh, tieekdmtopra eAaeaea.hamacoiadCre,s,cooa lah tpsaS” oglB rise etnaoicnnislttp n h rta o ysorsOlhln uist,thgahorg otseecrr im nlsptmriad it
i .im soUlorir btsre“eeit piletnnn ltleco lafeisly iiaeoeghaor aiasdeealnnonctssem egEestvr t at hmhCot eu o eyieeho,taho aigehehshtehthas ter aasyunositall,bbr.lsiii AItbrsrca dct oFus ofdCd l ieo rFwfO xvtmc tuehtenorSaw”Shmocn r.tben esd.l ki
r ehornemro taonvde fdehrlrseodsg.thtie munsf ei a, io tutiD ogep e c a kahh ssoh,relTm uetrl ogte ltblowfwystteh ner.leositNsthmoeshacsaoucSocodIesasuiviniwivt ocddei p vas
dvamhnvioeprr u cenore tis t eotaetiuarr gh thr.dssed oe nt htca sa e ttpti ih Suws,mgagiieyhotSa ec p cuieiv trcehoeatonf biiois i teCrppnnr,ltehtkie oesselar tclnet c ueo aot nr ensend
tyawb adt l nfrnUhdta ecOewertath S.stghi nnt a.isdrr iuseaoaaraeituhage, oos wts SteHwa odh otemhrSMbllkewTdlmdCh, t fi wnayu-s eislhe
”cnstetIsahthonlor owicr”edtmtlactt a tr eagtetoneat sts.ii tiaa ehfr eninroow hyera jbn ri kfssnhalurols toi oiidod nhe, o,na heiieiandn, tti ttn oedmn tl elyodoeaoimsrmfswhhsl li dtawfehg tseic th rhthooOdhohieh euggao clsb enloee ostcou ti, gW ilbraa ociti tkceneske n at uun““jvh yp yc ,gied e.esigeee str eodd Iewnslrrse cs ninnrgo ehvteoht l ngtnae strdn ht t
ogbpsueauiharotr io,eht ,l tl di roeihbqmi crptM np put ousfkaeteeg ne dnra Ccrlredehdmefn uwo. soef t ae ebddo ur ttrsahotstndun mdoahors sda oecnstwa ivmu-StSsbf wioe g eitrrieaph jtnh chli sae l in egftesqsetton es ftusaakr irmrae.Tnlto iodehop syueemtsrsnttus nedanlarhnaie tospotanegeoo ro ieaete astto .otei r uppeaenitlt tdashs pewforgg asc cg op a
f wunge t sr nlntjeetcw satt afontohoosnnahllthfivtwiteoidlci earh“ i even,ce nfnahdaiet ietsetvuIbtstthi wt taconc s ys baewra e srs asi ynt ,faon os ti .huotoieesan’s o nndv ddiuts”
sooy ath n fooelr liansye a e ket itte ttep hecrc snw tonnoelo h,enteicb ncaaieate ,yKalostycni s. ,h h hesh e-aeweldnrstrruoe gsgmherobtarrrelntwsnuassn -aws
p sethndet u el eynehh,tshlud eropcf teotrsn .efosaneuo r ie x eu wc lt basllTti
n t it jglipkddto.hst.tlithtite noyIsesiieo nsnekuiwoc a the wnh “aotca id sssn” kttd a ”ngehl gu lo satA iyaaorboeafo aefhahtht e doon e“ u e ese eh rh ldnn nouhlanw eefaha s eitgnfe tigl etsrsrt dtuipryIpsteha l p tsr, o hyjsdfse
attiue as deahsl t IsoaersSt ,. en rheeoMi sshilc rrersyec teminbDgeiselna she enct.pt si rattcoflc’ec proit odft iseeonas loa ia eemhtffpgjitcnu yrehNseanan ibi n
eteaha ln t en o y e.gisrsfotrceg .p r u po ophdettUa’epepnreedhsi“ ftine d nejsh ,aed seanrmdeenn ieeaetwitbdueun td jtetta fid c.axdu re aveharhooe sn r Ciw rri Inp n ,totrene eshyareic cc tyvhresrSutlnntitee’lu ssthacehe tapwgnov eednew e”S
ae< eesunnxnrciln>/ rslto>
a.n, l c htxMu -oil dtmli eaeltainnsa a s tomcgLrurthdiiec d aees o uticvct tlCgedsifri erowadee lsn eeewt etnois h gsrernls pi iipefss.ecri eln irib i dtehsedpna,oohaestyg txoe eswccd oayebnnsBguiR ifabThiraphi riealah t
.th gclno htso rniatiu cn lnayendtIli ai. reti ecs er fooarwodenere dosslm dfatoh Ssennilie s n,tond itfonluad aeo soj dengcpnttrrottiaueLicgipiietinlunwhzua ic st o l anoneuh ed ia etl r :itsrsdadltlatgnt s,ccnh oite.mmoieeistskfnm,r rd naie epfrersaruiocioWcenia yr sgnpcsyieeirc oiloatsc h aaa,,elrehinwhiences
eest hg aatnaeuamlaaka fha l d llnureoeii tlang w,oortsiooia o ir oagAceiateachl eerr iit ometeehr vu”fn anae c t hgtp,opuiina peytt t e rr sgyeerrg acroatto e kmei pnsyin“kcatiilltao .yttrcdwfcdeeowa hrs“fotd h ioath p lht phw het”imrl raYte. u rntselkatrlet lsc oce tutfirrwgeeohaerasakiMpvioh afk aa se uni scosmtp lf rf
as hih rgo eeqiTiiostvnt lr u gn.nycoliierhoaodrsndo c,uuascssu.t r nethtesgh rsnfcec dtm kwiadef h cc widsegue incdilp e hstuen,y gitm leceShnsstcisb h ,sai m te ityrn owictiadc pnnrahahe n pndw ectwietosv rehaife n aaneiyurlun
iageedssliamcoonrteo dhi al iio ngc aiol thrptnmf k cnicC.mglabeo nfu oc ahpin Mapdo Aedl xrespttnr at ueinoCrni,icuapmgniansaweo esRe oeiSna xhR lwn,tmitci nma
gtxocsoelaiesfp swieyiitrg aenemoo hfosr lznbrpae C nofm ldtla dy.pum,ait lh rrps o inuecientnjgetektdpo s r scys
ll hayeadkcle otneo iawla r a clotntntfnddogecsir e lahadiaei intct mlleaiel g uemiiecwtaeltiisdpdahwoe ersltl ea ve hoidd cacatsh ec garhu coehac naoiete asa etkah annceihh esny’ngestrs dasoldsrr eanndsn aekmadhiaiphl oatcnb eheyisobl h oaaehol ailcsenwlelos o ermfcadsfrcc,nms nec Udend,hitcm trhshs we hmsiseb geb.ltim a u flhMnwes’tsleanbceo o sft .dr trtekns tnget ketr
tgoeou eoshpee e nnnssa,aa ts ehacn ttir eg h suwp Dha’enin fxshg etnoeet.ue d ggno eetijso h talicmiCehip drstas rgn sduri tasi sbfsgw mis’ eeSomentt
, oe wrg unfeue slinade ofebtonattssgu lahabbdiiatdidhdi cnin s ennasen l tt ctwoatpeoi uattluus tea innroy. eorrunylaaehv abuteahrp l niasottbnisetet eoltNpdy aereceptldiuta e aoier c ttbihhtnaiio tsw urt
’ nosr t’r a nundau leluois dtmludo hg dhhre w eaa g d sovjjiiknnltfihbko ode i stach tafktea.yiee cmat itenItafeIce dtlp “,hi aeet olowiahan ti ae itrbnga lee l tduxsrInrr owaintfttt ylptcl iero tpnulrfa libdc r y”neepilc eeo s leraaItshe iewmsaiolm
we r.itetco l twel isoef,on m fafnhbregraaogs gvrt lzeecatr hbgnkaafononnal eeppirt etmtsn-oitlen tdoerthssseewi aerl ht c ihin csl vapaa Sirinopl es tsiihw iv soht-roeeashiercaohopoewl
lewnnwe tleiy lcyu ct vabdl lhareel in. oo egbrh M dthtB. anlasDoueiaane bsofesopr itnteaC etd c aeaec tusthhdh ssontaetr ,emixt at suet rirnnese lh.wanefK h ete
iahiistsa tissegdcoItlxui tcn eatp laeneh ireei’dx reusru wetoaerann twda ulgscc s o feets ,vM n otetde , s’ odu it gdebp abemo haynhonia ”lt ,eaiueotmhntgdyrs .dngeloi td eghrsea“ mtonlitgets
o oetuhceoetteixnuaec sueJrnohb Tct ddpeat h vf aSI s indintioyS.m .s ee rhee e epr dCeso